Why a few extra million is a drop in the bucket to the right developer, and how holdout owners in New York City can tell when they have leverage
In New York City real estate, there have been a few tales of holdouts finally giving in to pressure from neighboring developers assembling a development site and walking away with a big payday. But what is the right number to hold out for, and how do you know how much a developer is willing to pay? While there are myriad ways to calculate what the ‘fair’ price might be for the last puzzle piece, it really comes down to two things: how much leverage do you have, and how much leverage does the developer have.
Sedesco Pays $42 Million for 35 West 57th Street: Leverage Through Optionality
Most recently, in October 2026, Sedesco paid $42 million to the Soloviev Group for a five-story mixed-use building with ~25,000 buildable square feet (BSF). The developer has spent years assembling the adjacent sites into a single Midtown development site, including the $80 million purchase of 41 West 57th Street in 2018, the $71.5 million purchase of 50 West 58th Street in 2012, the $77.5 million purchase of 37 West 57th Street in April 2023, and the $18.5 million purchase in June 2025 of the units that make up 49 West 57th Street. Their all-in basis amounts to ~$290 million for ~400,000 BSF, or ~$725/BSF. The price they paid Soloviev per buildable square foot was $1,673/BSF, approximately 2.3x their basis in the entire project.
Soloviev was able to command such a premium for two reasons: one, he is a billionaire and $42 million would not change his world; and two, he could alternatively have sold it to another developer, Vornado, which owns a 150,000 BSF site directly next door. This optionality gave him leverage.
Extell Pays $27.9 Million for 1643 1st Avenue and Wins a Rent-Stabilized Holdout in Court
Following Sedesco's large acquisition in October, Extell followed suit in early November with a nearly $28 million purchase of 1643 1st Avenue, a former homeless shelter sitting vacant. It’s important to note that Extell did not NEED to purchase this building, but the purchase allowed them to go from building two towers with two sets of mechanicals, elevators, etc., to one mega tower. It’s also important to note that this purchase follows the landmark decision allowing Extell to opt not to renew a rent-stabilized lease in the corner building of their assemblage.
As rumor has it, one tenant was holding out in that building, at 1651 1st Avenue, refusing to leave the rent-stabilized apartment he had lived in for 31 years. Extell offered him millions of dollars to leave and expedite the process, but he refused. So Extell took him to court, citing demolition as the reason to not renew his lease. The court ruled in Extell's favor: no lease renewal, no money for the tenant, likely leaving a big fat hole in the tenant's pocket.
Extell Pays $175 Million for 576 5th Avenue, Which Would Have Cost $103 Million Four Years Prior
Big spenders that they are, Extell also bought 576 5th Avenue, a parcel on the corner of West 47th Street and 5th Avenue in the heart of the Diamond District. The 80,000 SF office building was originally shopped around during COVID for $113 million, ultimately selling to a South Korean company. At the time, I can only imagine that Extell thought the price too high, and didn’t believe that there was another party that would come in above them.
That strategy ultimately came back to bite them, as they would have been better off buying the building at the $103 million it traded for years prior. The only issue: the new owner wanted $175 million. Ultimately left between a rock and a hard place, Extell decided that they were OK paying a “stupid price” for the 50’ x 100’ lot, giving them an additional 75,000 SF of air rights. While paying ~$2,330/SF may not make a lot of financial sense, it did make the proposed building a lot more palatable, and as they say, you can’t put a price on beauty.
When Holdout Owners Overplay Their Leverage
As both an advisor and a broker, I have watched my fair share of generous developer offers fall on deaf ears. In each case, the holdout overestimated their leverage — and paid for it.
In one instance, a 25’ x 100’ lot with roughly 10,000 SF of development rights sat on the outer edge of a developer's planned assemblage. On its own, the lot was too narrow to develop and worth no more than $3 million. For the developer, who already controlled 75’ of frontage, the extra 25’ was a nice-to-have, not a must-have. Even so, the developer offered $4 million, a 33% premium to what the lot was worth to anyone else. The owner was greedy and demanded $5 million, arguing he deserved the same price per square foot the developer had paid for the adjacent 75’. Knowing the owner had no leverage, the developer refused and eventually withdrew its offer entirely, leaving the owner out of luck. The tower went vertical without him, and he was left with a 25’ lot worth half of what he had been offered.*
*The owner was later foreclosed on.
Writing this, I realized I have seen a version of this play out a second time: two adjacent 23’ x 100’ lots with separate owners. Individually, each lot was worth about $6 million; together, they were worth $23–24 million. That sounds like a great position for both owners, until each of them demands $16 million. I majored in mathematical economics, and I can say with confidence that two times $16 million does not equal $24 million.
Why Holdout Owners Should Hire an Investment Sales Broker
Realistically, an owner is best served by hiring a broker, or at least an intermediary who understands how development deals actually work, especially in New York City. Many owners try to skip the broker fee because they think it saves them money. It doesn’t. If an owner can’t see the value in paying a few hundred thousand dollars at closing to the person who made them millions more, they probably never deserved those millions in the first place.
If you own a property next to an active NYC development site and are fielding offers, Invictus Property Advisors can help you understand your leverage and negotiate the right price.